Mailing List
Home
Forum Home
Linux - General Red Hat Linux discussion list
Installation - Getting started with Red Hat Linux
Enterprise Linux 3 - Discussion of Red Hat Enterprise Linux 3 (Taroon)
Red Hat Linux 9 - Discussion of Red Hat Linux 9 (Shrike)
Red Hat Linux 7.2 - Discussion of Red Hat Linux 7.2 (Enigma)
Red Hat Linux 7.3 - Discussion of Red Hat Linux 7.3 (Valhalla)
Apache Web Server
Oracle database, Microsoft SQL server ...
Subjects
Subject: application/x mplayer2 plugin
RPM error: db4 error(16) from dbenv >remove: Device or resource
   busy
Command stream end of file while reading
Subject: X Windows problem (xauth)
Subject: Upgrading openoffice 1 1 rpm
Subject: FTP: connection refused
Subject: FTP: connection refused
mount: /dev/cdrom: is not a valid block device
Dell Precision 650, RedHat 9, no sound
how to trace the cause resulting in the crash of bind server
Virus on the list
UNINSTALL RPM MYSQL
usb pen drives: mounting as a user
Subject: broadcom network interface
make mrproper
Couldn 't open PID file /var/run/named/named pid Permission denied
sendmail configuration on redhat
kernel 2 6 and /dev/sound/mixer not found
Subject: Promise 378 controller
Subject: Problem using up2date
mrtg step by step howto/configuration for a newbie?
Compiling and Installing Kernel 2 6
Can 't locate module ppp0, can 't locate module ppp compress 21
Subject: Lotus Notes under Wine
HOW I CAN MAKE BOOTABLE FLOPPY DISKET
/etc/security/limits conf question
Intel E/1000 driver
rpm database corrupt
Command stream end of file while reading
qla2300 modules
 
Subject: Looking for license donations

Subject: Looking for license donations

2007-05-05       - By Axel Thimm

 Back
Reply:     1     2     3     4  

Hi,

based on Red Hat's kind initiative on offering RHEL licenses three
years ago ATrpms has been building packages for RHEL3/4/5 on
i386/x86_64/ppc since (special thanks go to Chris Kloiber and Greg
Dekoenigsberg for making that happen), and have become a major 3rd
party package repository in the RHEL and clones community.

What was once a two-platform support on one distro has grown into 3
distros on three platforms increasing the number of licenses used for
pulling base packages and updates to build packages against.

This must also have made it increasingly difficult for people inside
Red Hat to justify licensing for ATrpms' builders, so that there had
been some "outages" in the past where no new updates could be built
against due to expired, not-renewed licenses (thankfully these update
outages were short and not kernel update happened during that time).

This is less a problem with RHEL compared to say Fedora due to the
very stable ABI, but especially in situations with kernel (security)
errata which imply rebuilds of all kmdls it is very painful to both
the repo maintainer and the users.

Five of the 10 currently used licenses will expire in less than ten
days and all attempts to renew them have not worked out until now (the
other five will expire by December). There are several paths that
ATrpms can take:

o Find someone to donate RHEL licenses
o Reduce the number of required licenses by dropping platforms.
 ppc has not been the greatest hit judging from the download
 statistics, so it could probably be canceled
o Reduce the number of required licenses by dropping distros.
 RHEL3 has seen its glory days pass by as well.
o Switch from using RHEL to using CentOS/SL.
 Until now ATrpms could claim to be safe from any possible rebuild
 bugs, while CentOS/SL make a great job in reproducing the API/ABI of
 RHEL there is always a small possibility to miss something.
o A mix of the above

I'd prefer to keep building against RHEL, e.g. to continue to utilize
the set of 10 licenses, that's why there's this cry for help.
--
Axel.Thimm at ATrpms.net

--
Taroon-list mailing list
Taroon-list@(protected)
https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/taroon-list